Ihtijaj (Argumentation) [Abu Mansur Ahmad Tabarsi, Saiyyed Amir Husayn Sarkishian] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. In the introduction. Al–Ihtijaj by Allama Abu Mansur Ahmad Tibrisi Vol Uploaded by Syed Naqvi. Islamic Urdu Book. Copyright: Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC). Download. Al-Tabarsi and the Distortion of the Qur’an. Al-Tabarsi mentions in his book al- Ihtijaj (vol. 1 pg. ) while discussing the argument of Amir al-Mu’minin `Ali radiya Llahu `anhu.

Author: Kir Jugar
Country: Kenya
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Spiritual
Published (Last): 11 September 2007
Pages: 388
PDF File Size: 2.48 Mb
ePub File Size: 14.62 Mb
ISBN: 522-6-97380-174-6
Downloads: 99046
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Samura

Or to those who came after and tried their best to find excuses for him? So what is the matter with those who disbelieve, hastening from before you, O Muhammad. Allah covered their eyes and set veils upon their hearts from pondering over it that is why they left it as is, and He veiled it from those who would seek to distort it. Seems like you didn’t read my 4th post on this thread, where I quoted: Why can we see shias so frustrated when someone accuse ahlalbayt in deficiency, and we see you honoring and respecting people who accuse Quran in the same?

Israr Ahmedand was quoting from their own works of history, this does not prove that the person is a Nasibi. This is not a very solid argument or even a proper comparison.

Now you tell me: The importance the work has possessed since its compilation as the standard reference work for all Shi’ite studies can hardly be overemphasized. Allamah Shushtari has written a treatise on Sahw of the Prophet in Salat and no one has labelled him a disbeliever. I narrated the hadiths of the ascribed exegesis to Imam al-‘Askari a by its chain of narrators: The most famous and authoritative collections of Shi’ite hadith s are four works which, in terms of their importance for Shi’ism, correspond to the Six Correct Collections in Sunni Islam.

Al-Ihtijaj (Tabarsi)

He then explains to us these three categories vol. They are generally treated the same way Mirza Nuri’s book is treated.

You see this normal? All he believed was that some verses are missing like taharsi someone believed the Imams or the Prophet could forget at times. That would be an extremely fallacious move to discredit someone’s personality or all of their other works based on one work – without having read the other works or not knowing about their general methodology.


Correct me if I am wrong, but you argue that Tabarsi simply believed that some parts of Quran are missing.

What would you say about this scholar, who compiled book to prove that Quran is deficient? He collects together traditions in which their discussions with opponents have been recorded. Al-Khowansari says in Rowdat al-Jannat vol. Started by Hani Quran-Tafseer. I am sure you can find some far-fetched justifications for the poor man, just like many of your scholars do for ‘Abdullah bin Mas’ud tabaarsi he decided not to put Surah al-Falaq and al-Naas in his codex because he didn’t deem them to be part tabasi the Qur’an.

Go To Topic Listing. April 22, This is the category which I mentioned its meaning is only known by the one whose mind is ttabarsi, whose understanding is profound, and whose skill of differentiation is correct. In the very beginning of the work, he explicitly states:. If you would pay attention, talk here is not about general shia belief in completeness of Quran.

Al-Ihtijaj (book)

To his own book? There the author of the article ” Hadith ” is aware tbaarsi there is some difference between Shi’ism and Sunnism on the question of which hadith s are included, but he thinks that it lies in the fact that the Shi’ite collections accept “only traditions traced through ‘Ali’s family. Although it is well known that the first “pillar of Islam” is the profession of faith, which begins with a statement of the Divine Tabaesi, Western scholars have tended to explain the Islamic belief in God’s Oneness as a relativity simple-minded affirmation of the existence of only one God.

He wrote in ithijaj of “Faslul Khitab” of our shaykh an-Noori. These are two different topics so please don’t mix things up. For you to come and tell me not to play word games shows your lack of inexperience and ignorance.

Mention, O Muhammadthe Day We will call forth every people with their record of deeds. In these writings we see that already in the first centuries of Islam the Divine Unity was affirmed in terms reminiscent of the subtlety of later “theosophical” Sufism, but still completely steeped in the peculiar spiritual aroma of the tabarei itself. As for the “earth” in this location, it refers to the place of knowledge and life.


al-Tabrasi author of al-Ihtijaj and Tahreef

His al-Tawhid collects traditions which illustrate the profession of God’s Unit. Hence the selections stress the principles and fundamentals usul of Islam, while they tend to ignore the branches and secondary aspects furu. The guy wrote a whole book on it trying to prove his point – how is that so easy? Yes, indeed some shia thinkers tried to reject accusation that Noori wrote that book, by changing its heading.

The sermons, sayings, prayers and writings translated here present a cross section of Shi’ite religious thought with an emphasis upon that which is most basic for the religion itself and most universal and hence understandable in the eyes of non-Muslims.

And yet he again honored, and respected scholar in shia world. This response is sufficient for you on this topic; indeed the law of Taqiyyah prohibits the explicit mention of anything more. It was compiled in the Safavid period by the famous theologian Muhammad Baqir Majlisi d.

Others who may feel that the present translation does not do justice to the literary qualities of the text may try their own hand at rendering it into English. If the Quran is not protected, then it is not a hujja on mankind.

Al-Ihtijaj (book) – WikiShia

Al-Ihtijaj is one of the reliable books among Shi’a scholars. No, because we know that they been altered.

Some of those who made this mistake are Amin al-Istarabadi and before him, the author of Mashayikh al-Shi’a and before him, Muhammad b. What do you know about shaykh Noori Tabarsi? Edit Edited October 13, by skamran